I got four of these out form the library and it kinda feels unfair to compare them to the other two. The physical presence of an Art Book seems like such an important part of it!

I really like the illustrated Earthsea book but I'm not sure how to compare it to the others.

Ok maybe I just hate comparing things I like to other things I like an ranking them -- Hugo voting is hard!

I'm mad at the D&D book for being all "woe is use oppressed geeks" while utter failing to acknowledge how frankly offensive a lot of the early D&D art is.