The bird has flown
Sep. 8th, 2023 01:36 pmIn the end, the thing about Musk deactivating Starlink connectivity near the Crimean coast during a crucial Ukrainian military mission was the final straw. I feel grimly amused that this was the ethical line too far, the point at which I decided continuing to use Twitter violated my own personal morality, when there were many previous moments which could have brought me to this point.
It's a bit easier for me, as I've never really felt at home on Twitter at any point. I joined the platform in 2009, as a reward to myself for completing my MPhil (hilariously, at the time, all its biggest evangelists were touting the platform as somewhere fun and friendly, with none of the toxicity and abuse of blog comments sections; that sentiment — which I saw repeated again and again about other platforms — led me to conclude that it's the small, relatively connected initial user base, with roughly shared political and cultural values, that creates these 'fun and friendly' atmospheres, rather than anything magical about specific platforms), and kind of drifted vaguely along there ever since.
The good relationships with people I've had on Twitter are relationships that (with a handful of exceptions), were built and continue either in person or on other online platforms, so leaving Twitter will not rupture those connections. The relationships I made solely through Twitter were (with a handful of exceptions) not perceived in the same way by both parties; for the most part, I viewed them as being much more meaningful and important than the other people did — something that was brought home to me a few years ago with painful clarity in circumstances that still cause me a lot of hurt when I think about them. This was nobody's fault, it was just mismatched assumptions, but for this reason I don't feel much grief about the withering of connections that will result from me leaving the platform. They will just become other context-specific friendships that didn't survive the removal of that very specific context.
I've known for about a month that I wanted to leave. The realisation came to me when a bunch of people started vague-tweeting about some SFF publishing drama, all explanations of the drama were locked on threads on Bluesky, I realised I had no idea what was going on, and I realised that I had no interest in finding out. I'm free! I thought.
I'm not, at this point, moving to either Bluesky or Mastodon (which is where most people seem to have decamped). I'm burnt out by leaping immediately to a new platform which might be the next big thing, for fear of missing out. My needs are met quite well by the combination of other platforms (plus in-person social circles) I currently use, and I want to continue nesting in the slower-paced, text-based, comment- and discussion-heavy internet.
The sole thing I will miss, and which really can't be replicated with ease, was the access — in one place, in English, or with a fairly good instant translation tool — to expert commentary and analysis on the politics and cultures whose perspectives don't get much focus within English-language mainstream media. I followed, for example, stateless Arab Spring activists, Kurdish refugees livetweeting from within Australia's offshore detention centres, Turkish journalists, Belorusian civil society activists, military commentators providing detailed analyses of the Russian invasion of Ukraine, academics from Uzbekistan, and so on. It made it easy for me to gain at least a superficial understanding of the context behind breaking news in a wide variety of regions, as well as events that were important locally but not making the headlines globally. I've tried to sign up for newsletters (and import the newsletter feeds into Dreamwidth) from many of these people when I can, but obviously that's not possible in every case, and my own understanding will suffer. But it's not worth it to stick around just for this, and I've always been a bit suspicious of things that are too easy — so maybe it's good that I'll now be forced to work a bit harder to gain understanding and perspective of current affairs in other countries.
So now it just remains for me to delete the relevant account. I'm slowly going through other platforms and removing reference to my Twitter account, deleting the Twitter widget embedded on my book review blog, and so on. The next step will be to use a tool to delete all tweets, replies, retweets and likes (as a friend who did this recently said, I don't trust Musk not to use my supposedly 'deleted' Twitter account to train his new AI tool), and finally deleting the account in question.
It will be the end of an era, I suppose, but an era about which my feelings are decidedly mixed.
It's a bit easier for me, as I've never really felt at home on Twitter at any point. I joined the platform in 2009, as a reward to myself for completing my MPhil (hilariously, at the time, all its biggest evangelists were touting the platform as somewhere fun and friendly, with none of the toxicity and abuse of blog comments sections; that sentiment — which I saw repeated again and again about other platforms — led me to conclude that it's the small, relatively connected initial user base, with roughly shared political and cultural values, that creates these 'fun and friendly' atmospheres, rather than anything magical about specific platforms), and kind of drifted vaguely along there ever since.
The good relationships with people I've had on Twitter are relationships that (with a handful of exceptions), were built and continue either in person or on other online platforms, so leaving Twitter will not rupture those connections. The relationships I made solely through Twitter were (with a handful of exceptions) not perceived in the same way by both parties; for the most part, I viewed them as being much more meaningful and important than the other people did — something that was brought home to me a few years ago with painful clarity in circumstances that still cause me a lot of hurt when I think about them. This was nobody's fault, it was just mismatched assumptions, but for this reason I don't feel much grief about the withering of connections that will result from me leaving the platform. They will just become other context-specific friendships that didn't survive the removal of that very specific context.
I've known for about a month that I wanted to leave. The realisation came to me when a bunch of people started vague-tweeting about some SFF publishing drama, all explanations of the drama were locked on threads on Bluesky, I realised I had no idea what was going on, and I realised that I had no interest in finding out. I'm free! I thought.
I'm not, at this point, moving to either Bluesky or Mastodon (which is where most people seem to have decamped). I'm burnt out by leaping immediately to a new platform which might be the next big thing, for fear of missing out. My needs are met quite well by the combination of other platforms (plus in-person social circles) I currently use, and I want to continue nesting in the slower-paced, text-based, comment- and discussion-heavy internet.
The sole thing I will miss, and which really can't be replicated with ease, was the access — in one place, in English, or with a fairly good instant translation tool — to expert commentary and analysis on the politics and cultures whose perspectives don't get much focus within English-language mainstream media. I followed, for example, stateless Arab Spring activists, Kurdish refugees livetweeting from within Australia's offshore detention centres, Turkish journalists, Belorusian civil society activists, military commentators providing detailed analyses of the Russian invasion of Ukraine, academics from Uzbekistan, and so on. It made it easy for me to gain at least a superficial understanding of the context behind breaking news in a wide variety of regions, as well as events that were important locally but not making the headlines globally. I've tried to sign up for newsletters (and import the newsletter feeds into Dreamwidth) from many of these people when I can, but obviously that's not possible in every case, and my own understanding will suffer. But it's not worth it to stick around just for this, and I've always been a bit suspicious of things that are too easy — so maybe it's good that I'll now be forced to work a bit harder to gain understanding and perspective of current affairs in other countries.
So now it just remains for me to delete the relevant account. I'm slowly going through other platforms and removing reference to my Twitter account, deleting the Twitter widget embedded on my book review blog, and so on. The next step will be to use a tool to delete all tweets, replies, retweets and likes (as a friend who did this recently said, I don't trust Musk not to use my supposedly 'deleted' Twitter account to train his new AI tool), and finally deleting the account in question.
It will be the end of an era, I suppose, but an era about which my feelings are decidedly mixed.